The Case Of The Day – South Sea Company And GameStop

First last day of school for me!

In one of the courses today, we discussed the South Sea Company in 1720 in UK, when Sir Isaac Newton, representing “the smartest in the world”, didn’t do well in the stock market.

South Sea Company
Source: sovereignman.com

Also today, we saw news that Melvin Capital Management received $2.75 billion cash injection, as it has lost 30% in the first 3 weeks of 2021, due to its short bets including shorting GameStop (NYSE: GME). Melvin “had been one of the best performing hedge funds on Wall Street in recent years”, representing “the smartest of the smartest” in today’s world.

GameStop’s stock soared 245% in 2021 through Jan 22.

It closed at $6.68 on August 31, 2020, when Ryan Cohen revealed his 5.8 million shares purchase, or 9% stake. It closed at $76.79 today (Jan 25) – some 11.5x return if you buy at $6.68.

GameStop stock price in from Jan 19 – Jan 25 | Source: Yahoo Finance, author

The $2.75 billion cash includes $2 billion from Citadel and its partners, and $750 million from Point72. Melvin founder Gabe Plotkin was from Point72’s predecessor firm.

Takeaways:

1/ Predicting human behavior is much harder than physics or quarterly earnings.

2/ Leverage is the multiplier of actions.

3/ The “smartest” people might get it right – but lots of things can go wrong before that happens.