An Update on Tesla

In the previous post on Tesla’s productions & deliveries (2018 Q4), a not-so-good Q1 is somehow foreseeable, when Model 3 has little QoQ growth from Q3 to Q4 despite the holiday season and a fade in US tax credit at year-end.

Tesla has more concerning issues.

Depressed Margins

The mass production of Model 3 in 2018 H2 helped to improve the automotive sales gross margin in Q3 and Q4.

However, due to the price reduction in 2019 Q1, less absorption of fixed cost and more international deliveries, the automotive sales gross margin went back to the 18-19% region in 2019 Q1.

While production in China is expected to reach a rate of 2,000 vehicles a week by the end of 2019 (according to Elon Musk), the gross margin of automotive sales will remain <20% for 2019 I think (with model 3 basic)

Tesla said the capital spend (CapEx) per unit of capacity for Shanghai factory is expected to be less than half of that of the Model 3 line in Fremont. Not 50% COGS though.

Model S & X Halved

Number of produced is at ~56% of 2018 Q4.

Number of delivered is at ~44% of 2018 Q4.

Though, Tesla reaffirmed its prior guidance of 360,000 to 400,000 vehicle deliveries in 2019, thanks to the confidence in Model 3.

China Sales

Although China (China and Europe mainly) sales in 2018 decreased compared to 2017, Tesla’s March performance in China is exceptional, with 9,273 in total (Model 3: 7515; Model X: 1490; Model S: 268)

Tesla Vehicles Sold in China 2019 Q1 | Source: Che Jing She, sohu.com

Many attributed the jump in sales to the “one time” price adjustment in China, including a ¥341 drop in the most expansive Model X (P100D), which then corrected by a general 3% increase.

Source: sohu.com

But the ongoing sales numbers is still in question.

China’s EV market has been increasingly competitive. And in April, a video of a parked Model S emitting smoke and bursting into flames seconds later was spreading across China’s Weibo, which doesn’t do any help.

 

Coffee Chains in China

In a previous post about Starbucks, we talked about its potential in China.

China’s coffee consumption will explode, even considering major cities alone. Younger generations will consume more coffee and they will represent an increasing proportion of the overall urban population.

China coffee consumption potential | Source: Starbucks 6/19 Presentation

Everyone sees the market and opportunities – one of the most eye-catching player is Luckin Coffee (瑞幸咖啡), who just filed to be listed on Nasdaq.

Image result for Luckin Coffee
Source: TechCrunch

The expansion in terms of coverage & number of stores is very impressive: 9 stores by the end of 2017 and 2,370 stores by the end of 2019Q1, although most (91.3 %) of them are pick-up stores (see above).

By comparison, in May 2018, Starbucks announced that it is planning to build nearly 3,000 new stores in mainland China over the next few years (from 3,300 in 2018Q1 to 6,000 before the end of 2022).

Things to notice:

    • Luckin Coffee outsourced delivery services mainly to S.F. Express (顺丰控股SHE: 002352)
    • Luckin’s investors are mainly related to UCAR INC. (神州优车 NEEQ:838006)
    • Didn’t see GIC or BlackRock or Legend Capital as major shareholders (>5%)
    • Loss is significant: ¥527 million operation loss on ¥361 million revenue in 2019Q1 (-110.1%)
    • No significant revenue growth from 2018Q4 to 2019Q1: 465,433k to 478,510k (+2.8%)
    • There was a decrease in advertising cost: 127,372 in 2018Q4 -> 93,080 in 2018Q4 -> 40,143 in 2019Q1

Disney+ Is Coming

When all the fellow streaming platforms are adding their original content capacities, on April 11, the biggest original content provider Disney Group finalized the pricing ($6.99/month) of its own streaming platform, Disney+. And the official US launch date is later this year on November 12.

Disney+ pricing | Source: Disney investor day presentation

Disney’s preparation and acquisition of BAMTech

Disney’s plan to launch its own streaming service has been around for quite some time. Its first official announcement was in August 2017 with Disney’s acquisition of an additional 42% of BAMTech for $1.58 billion, which gave Disney a controlling stake of 75%.

Source: disney.fandom.com

Before that, in August 2016, Disney acquired 33% of BAMTech (a spin-off from MLB’s broader digital business, MLB Advanced Media) for $1 billion.

BAMTech is the streaming technology provider for services including HBO NOW (launched in March 2015 with Apple being the exclusive launch partner; and Apple was promoting its Apple TV), National Hockey League (NHL), Major League Baseball (MLB), etc.

Disney Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Bob Iger talked about the streaming service on the BAML conference in September 2017.

What we’re going to do with the Disney direct-to-consumer app or platform is, first of all, we’re going to launch it in late 2019. We’re doing that for 2 reasons. First of all, as we exit the Netflix output deal, we don’t get access to our theatrical release movies until the beginning of ’19. Secondly, we wanted time to actually develop and build up original programming for the platform.

Following the 2016 transaction, Disney made plans to test BAMTech’s delivery and support of streaming video and other digital products from Disney|ABC Television Group and ESPN.

ESPN+ as a test-out

Following the 2017 transaction, Disney said it would launch its ESPN-branded multi-sport video streaming service in early 2018.

The new ESPN app and the ESPN+ service were launched in April 2018, provided by BAMTech. ESPN+ is priced at $4.99 a month or $49.99 a year.

What is different though, is that the content on ESPN+ is not a replacement of cable subscriptions (at least for now). ESPN Plus will not provide live access to ESPN’s main channels like ESPN and ESPN2 – you’ll still need a cable subscription to authenticate and watch. [TechCrunch]

new ESPN app and ESPN+ | Source: theverge.com

After all, ESPN is originally a cable business and sports are heavily rely on ads. ESPN+ is an ad-embedded streaming service (video ads).

In 10 month, the number of ESPN+ subscribers has reached 2 million.

On the other hand, ESPN itself (cable) lost 2 million subscribers in fiscal year 2018, with total subscribers of 86 million as of September 2018.

ESPN+ is expected to have 8-12 million subscribers by the end of FY 2024.

So Disney+ and its expectation

It will be one of (the most important one) the three pillars of Disney’s streaming services, alongside with ESPN+ and Hulu (will discuss separately).

Source: nscreenmedia.com

Its direct competitors are Netflix and HBO Now. Bob Iger has specifically said it would be priced lower than Netflix years ago.

Priced at $6.99 a month or $69.99 per year, Disney+ is $2 lower than Netflix’ new basic monthly plan. Netflix announced the new pricing for United States in January 2019 to replace it original $7.99/10.99/13.99 lineup, effective May 2019.

Netflix new pricing 2019 | Source: netflix.com

The contents are powerful, including Disney, Pixar, Marvel, Star Wars, and National Geographic, etc.

Disney+ contents | Source: variety.com & Bob Iger Twitter

It is targeting 60-90 million subscribers in five years, by the end of FY 2024 (September 2014) and 1/3 would be in the US.

Meanwhile, the Disney Channel has seen its subscribers ebb to 89 million, down from 92 million in fiscal 2017. [Variety]

And Netflix now has 148.8 million subscribers globally, 60.2 million from the US, as of 2019 Q1.

 

 

Zoom, How Not To Underestimate Its Usefulness And Influence

Zoom went on Nasdaq with the IPO price of $36 (target range of $33 to $35 per share), opened at ~$65 and closed at $62 (up 72%), making it in par with Lyft.

Several things to note here:

    • Zoom is relatively young. It maintained high growth (2018 revenue of $331 million, 2017 revenue of $151 million) and is expected to grow fast.
    • Zoom is making a net profit in 2018 (~2.3% profit margin) and has maintained a high gross margin (~80%).
Source: Zoom SEC Filing. Author
    • Growth in customers – “As of January 31, 2017, 2018 and 2019, we had approximately 10,900, 25,800 and 50,800 customers with more than 10 employees.” they “represented 69%, 75% and 78% of revenue
    • Market Size – In the US, business with
      • 10-19 employees: 46,635
      • 20-49 employees: 37,495
      • 50-249 employees: 23,065
      • 250 or more: 5,672
      • ~113k in total, so Zoom has another 50% room to grow (will be harder and more costly)

    • market penetration and growth opportunity in large enterprise customers – “greater than 50% of the Fortune 500 had at least one paid Zoom host, compared to only 4% that contributed more than $100,000 of revenue. We believe this demonstrates that our product has already gained a foothold in many of the largest enterprises in the United States, and there is a large opportunity to expand within these large enterprise customers”
    • Revenue per large enterprise customer will grow, easily – “Some of our larger enterprise customers start with a single deployment of Zoom Meetings with one team, location or geography, before rolling out our platform throughout their organization.” “As of January 31, 2017, 2018 and 2019, we had 54, 143 and 344 customers that contributed more than $100,000 of revenue in each of their respective fiscal years”
    • Zoom’s future depends on its business outside video conferencing; it could grow into an essential infrastructure for business operations; it could do more than video conferencing, but also scheduling, internal messaging and other management tools.

Zoom, Slack, Alibaba’s Dingding (DingTalk), WeChat for Enterprise will meetup in the future, in the battle of office app/platform.


Read More on Zoom’s IPO

Inevitable Inflation: Yet Another Example From Starbucks Rewards

Having lived for 3 years, the current Starbucks Rewards program will end on April 15, 2019. The most direct comparison with the new program is the cost of “a free drink” – raised from 125 stars to 150 stars, a 20% inflation.

Starbucks Rewards April 2019 | Source: starbucks.com

Taking the previous revamp into account, from pre-April-2016 to post-April-2019, the program has been through 2 major changes with “points inflation” being the unchanged theme.

Let’s go back and do some calculation.

Program Redesign In April 2016

Starbucks Rewards has been through a redesign in April 2016, which transformed the transaction-based system into a value-based one.

Basically, before 2016, a $1.95 purchase is equivalent to a $5+ purchase in terms of stars earned (1 star; 12 starts = 1 free drink).

Starbucks Rewards revamp in April 2016 | Source: starbucks.com

Assuming a customer would use his/her stars for a free item with an average value of $5:

    • For a customer normally purchase an item of $2.5 to earn stars, the reward yield is approximately halved:
      • previously – 5/(12*2.5) = 16.67%
      • 2016 program – 5/(125/2/2.5*2.5) = 8%
    • For a customer normally purchase an item of $3.5 to earn stars, the reward yield is cut by 1/3:
      • previously – 5/(12*3.5) = 12%
      • 2016 program – 5/(125/2/3.5*3.5) = 8%

This change was resonating with a broader trend in “rewards” offered by consumer-facing industries such as airlines.

American Airlines is the latest major airlines that changed its rewards calculation from distance-based to money-based (announced in November 2015, effective August 2016)

United award miles redesign | Source: thepointsguy.com

Program Redesign In April 2019

As I mentioned at the beginning, the new program features a 20% inflation in terms of redeeming free drinks.

For dollar values, in the 2016-version, a Starbucks star is approximately worth 4 cents ($5/125); now, it is approximately 3.33 cents ($5/150). [to enhance the utility, one could order a venti drink and add a shot, making free drink ~$9 so a star is worth ~7 cents before and ~6 cents in the new program]

However, better yields could be found in hot coffee/tea.

    • hot tea usually has a price of $2.25/2.45/2.65 for tall/grande/venti size; simply taking it as a $2.5 value, a star = $2.5/50 = 5 cents
    • hot coffee (in brewed coffee category) usually has a price of $2.15/2.45/2.75 for tall/grande/venti size; in a venti size coffee, a star = $2.75/50 = 5.5 cents
      • there is a brewed product called Caffe Misto, which has a value of $3.35 for venti size, then a star = 6.67 cents
    • for lunch items, to make a star’s value above 4 cents, items needs to have a value of $8; and a $10 item for 5 cents value. Those items could be easily found in Starbucks’ new Mercato lunch category

The items above will maintain the value of stars and provide the valuable revenue diversification for Starbucks (especially for lunch items).

Plus, those items usually involve less manual work from baristas. They could enhance the overall productivity for Starbucks stores and increase the profit margin on average.

Finally, UBER S-1 Available

The S-1 of much anticipated Uber IPO is publicly available for the first time.

The valuation is said to be $90-100 billion, lower than previously reported.

That is also the reason that Lyft’s valuation is under pressure these days. It all makes that Lyft and Morgan Stanley have something to argue about… Lyft’s high valuation at IPO makes it difficult for Morgan Stanley and other banks to sell Uber. (and the pressure is much higher in such a big deal – $10 billion)

So relatively speaking, how much “higher” is Lyft valued?

  • Uber adjusted ebitda -1.85 billion vs. Lyft -944 million, ~2x
  • Uber revenue 11.27 billion vs. Lyft 2.16 billion, ~5x
  • Uber total trips 5.2 billion vs. Lyft 619 million, ~8x

Drone Delivery: A Real Thing

Future is closer than most will believe. Drone delivery is yet another example.

Imagined Reality

A few days ago (around April Fools’ Day), a FAKE video (by rendering) populated on Twitter, presenting an Amazon mothership equipped with drones.

However, this may not be far away from what the future will look like, especially for the drone part.

Amazon’s Plan

The idea could be seen in an Amazon patent US000009305280B120160405 filed in December 2014 and issued by the USPTO in April 2016.

Amazon patent for massive flying warehouses equipped with fleets of drones that deliver goods to key locations | Source: BBC

This is part of Amazon Prime Air program first announced in 2013. It looks more viable on the drone-only side, the first delivery made in December 2016 in Cambridge, UK.

Source: Amazon

And in 2017, an Amazon Prime Air drone dropped off some bottles of sunscreen for attendees at the company’s invite-only MARS conference in California. [The Verge]

US Pilot Programs Granted

In the US, FAA has selected 10 state, local and tribal governments for pilot programs in drone testing in May 2018. [More about the program]

    • Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma, Durant, OK
    • City of San Diego, CA
    • Innovation and Entrepreneurship Investment Authority, Herndon, VA
    • Kansas Department of Transportation, Topeka, KS
    • Memphis-Shelby County Airport Authority, Memphis, TN
    • North Carolina Department of Transportation, Raleigh, NC
    • North Dakota Department of Transportation, Bismarck, ND
    • The City of Reno, NV
    • University of Alaska-Fairbanks, Fairbanks, AK

Alphabet’s Wing in Australia – First to Commercial

Another exciting move is made by Alphabet’s Wing on Tuesday, which was granted approval in Canberra by Australian aviation authority CASA. Wing officially becomes world’s first drone delivery business according to The Guardian.

The deliveries will start with roughly 100 homes in the Canberra area. The drones are required to operate during daylight hours, banned from crossing over major roads and there’s a minimum distance they have to maintain from people on the ground.

Source: wing.com

Meanwhile, according to Wing’s website, they are going to launch the drone delivery service in Finland in spring of 2019, which will be their first operations in Europe.

Before this approval, in September 2016 at Virginia Tech, Wing (a Google X project then) has tested food delivery (Chipotle burritos) in the US for a tenth of a mile, maintaining the kind of line-of-sight flights that the FAA prefers (before any pilot programs). Virginia Tech is home to a U.S. FAA test site.

Wing made its first test in 2014 in Queensland, Australia, delivering a first aid kit, candy bars, dog treats and water to farmers.

Wing graduated from Google X in July 2018.

JD’s Drone in Asia

Earlier this year, JD.com announced that it has completed the first government approved drone flight in Indonesia, delivering backpacks and books to students in a local elementary school.

In China, JD has been approved for drone delivery services in provinces including Shanxi, Jiangsu, Qinghai, Guangdong, Hainan and Guangxi.

Snap’s Comeback Strategy With Partners

Snap (Before 2019 Q1)

Once characterized as the challenger for Facebook, Snap Inc. has faced fierce competitions from FB’s Instagram, which introduced a similar story feature in August 2016.

Snapchat vs. Instagram users comparison | Source: statista

Snap went IPO in March 2017 onto NYSE, valued at more  than $33 billion on the first day of trading, surpassing the previous $3 billion acquisition offer from Facebook in 2013 and a $30 billion acquisition offer from Google in 2016 (not verified, reported in August 2017, when Snap’s stock price had been declining to around $14).

Its road after IPO was not an easy one.

DAU growth peaked right before Instagram’s story launch. Other problems included the questionable change of Snapchat’s interface, departure of CFO (twice, first CFO departed in May 2018, second CFO departed in Jan 2019), etc.

Snap Partner Summit 2019 And Going Forward

The summit was held on April 4, on which new strategies and partnerships were detailed/projected.

By and large, Snap is learning from Facebook and is pivoting to becoming an “infrastructure”.

Broadly speaking, many firms are pursuing the infrastructure play: AWS wants to be the infrastructure for internet services (servers); Facebook & Google want to be the infrastructure of ads; Twitter & Youtube contents can be embedded in various ways, etc.

Snap now has updated its Snap Kit, to include a new Story Kit enabling other apps/sites to implant Snapchat Stories. Namely, users will be able to show/embed/insert their Snapchat Story in Tinder and Houseparty, two initial partners announced.

Snap Kit April 2019 | Source: kit.snapchat.com

Snapchat Audience Network is also being built to help other apps to monetize – a revenue-sharing practise to expand the audience/utility of Snap Ads, so that people who are not on Snapchat will be broadcasted the ads created by advertisers through Snap. [Read more about Facebook Audience Network]

Additionallly (besides ads), Snap announced the partnership with Fitbit to integrate Bitmoji avatars to Fitbit’s devices (Fitbit Ionic™ and Fitbit Versa™), a clock face that dynamically updates throughout the day based on your personal health and fitness data, activity, time of day, and weather. Also, Bitmoji will be seen on Venmo.

Snap’s Bitmoji on Fitbit | Source: theverge.com

 

Middlemen’s Hard Time… PBMs

It has been more than a month since the 7 major drug manufacturers’ CEOs testified before the congress on February 26.

One of the “problems” that pharma CEOs complained about was pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) or the middleman problem.

In a healthcare system involving drugmakers, PBMs, pharmacies, insurers, patients, etc., one of the premises behind CVS’s $70 billion acquisition of Aetna and Cigna’s $54 billion acquisition of Express Scripts might actually make them vulnerable in front of regulators: their bargain power.

CVS Health, Cigna, McKesson, Rite Aid, Walgreens… companies with relatively large exposure between pharmaceutical companies and patients/payers are having a very hard time.

Source: Author, Yahoo Finance

What’s ahead – on March 13, the same committee (Senate Finance Committee) said it has called 5 major PBMs to testify on April 3 (tomorrow…)

    • Cigna
    • CVS
    • Humana
    • OptumRx
    • Prime Therapeutics

They must have been prepared.

Stay stunned.

New Foreign Investment Law, Boao Forum for Asia 2019 And China Development Forum 2019

Following the closing (March 15) of National People’s Congress (NPC)’ 2019 annual meeting in Beijing, two important annual forums were held – China Development Forum 2019 (March and Boao Forum for Asia 2019

One of the major progress made during NPC’s annual meeting is the approval of the new foreign investment law #中华人民共和国外商投资法 (original link here)

The law was first introduced as a draft in 2015 and will come into effect on January 1, 2020.

The new foreign investment law will replace the “three foreign capital laws” – Law on Sino-Foreign Equity Joint Ventures #中外合资经营企业法, Law on Foreign-Capital Enterprises #外资企业法 and Law on Sino-Foreign Cooperative Joint Ventures #中外合作经营企业法, which were introduced in 1979, 1986 and 1988 respectively. They were updated along the way but structural/fundamental changes won’t be easy. (you can’t expect a law to be efficient and perfect after 30-40 years.. in a fast-changing environment)

China Development Forum is more focused on China. And of course, the newly-passed foreign investment law was discussed and introduced to all the CEOs/managements from foreign companies among others.

Again, on Boao Forum For Asia, Premier Li Keqiang reemphasized the plan to make detailed regulations to enforce the effective implementation of the foreign investment law.


Updates: