Tag: Finance

Retail Investors & Those Stocks Unavailable For Them To Buy

Didn’t believe I have the 4th blog on the recent stock price surge in GameStop, etc.

But here are 3 things to say.

1/ Platform restrictions

Yesterday, some restrictions were put on those stocks by TD Ameritrade and Charles Schwab (also owns TD Ameritrade; acquisition announced in Nov 2019). Robinhood also increased margin requirement on those stock to 100%.

Today, nearly all major stock trading platforms put restrictions on those stocks. Robinhood, notably, won’t show search result for those tickers/companies and only allow order to sell those position, including GME, AMC, KOSS, BBBY, BB, NOK, EXPR, etc.

Robinhood is under the spotlight, for its name and its innovation and mission to democratize investing. (See Robinhood CEO interview video at the end)

2/ Options that are still in play

I did a little excel calculation, only for call options that expire tomorrow (Jan 29), Feb 19, March 19 and April 16.

If GameStop closes at $300 tomorrow, and assuming all future calls are settled – the call options’ net value would be about $4.4 billion in total, and ~$1.7 billion for Jan 29 options alone.

What’s more crazy – the underlying stock count for those in-the-money call options expiring tomorrow are close to 10 million shares or 19% of the floating.

If GME closes at $200 tomorrow, those call options are worth $2.2 billion at least.

If GME closes at $400 tomorrow, those call options are worth $6.7 billion at least.

And there are more call options in other dates.

3/ Who is broke (don’t know)

In interviews and articles by brokers, (Robinhood, Webull, Interactive Brokers, etc.), they talked about clearing house requirement, etc.

It could also be the counter-party risk from the other side of those call options – as the Interactive Brokers Chairman said “so if there are $10-15 billion loss in there, somebody has to pay them. will they be able to pay is a big question”.

Don’t think people want to see some market makers or brokers or investment banks broke.

But – guess someone is or might be broke.

Robinhood CEO interview

Some further reading…

Webull CEO

ANTHONY DENIER: Well, it wasn’t our choice. Our clearing firm gave us a call and said we’re going to have to stop allowing new opening positions in the three names, AMC, GME, and KOSS. Highly volatile, and what happens is this is not a political decision. And unfortunately, it got political. I think, you know, I think it was once said that don’t let any good crisis go to waste. And that’s clearly what’s happening here.

And we’re seeing politicians jump on the bandwagon so they can get– so they can start trending on Twitter. But in reality, what’s going on is that there is a two-day settlement between if you buy the stock today, those brokerage firms that you bought that stock on have to fund that trade with the clearing central house called DTC for two whole days. And because of the volatility of stocks, DTC has made the cost of the collateral of the two-day holding period extremely expensive.

And we just can’t afford– well, we’re not a clearing firm, but our clearing firm simply cannot afford the cost to settle those trades. We cannot use customer funds to front that cost due to regulation. So the brokerages or the clearing firms have to go into their own pockets to do it. And they simply can’t afford the cost of that trade clearance. That is the reason why these stocks are coming off. It has nothing to do with the decision or some sort of closed room cigar– smoke-filled cigar room of Wall Street firms getting together to the dismay of the retail trader. This has to do with settlement mechanics of the market.

And:

ANTHONY DENIER: …There is no way that a customer would not be able to sell a position they hold. We are simply stopping opening of new positions. Liquidations can happen at any time. This is general market mechanics. We have customer protections in place. We would never stop a customer from being able to get out of a position. But currently, we are stopping customers from getting into a new position. And that has to do with it possibly.

Robinhood blog

Amid this week’s extraordinary circumstances in the market, we made a tough decision today to temporarily limit buying for certain securities. As a brokerage firm, we have many financial requirements, including SEC net capital obligations and clearinghouse deposits. Some of these requirements fluctuate based on volatility in the markets and can be substantial in the current environment. These requirements exist to protect investors and the markets and we take our responsibilities to comply with them seriously, including through the measures we have taken today.

Starting tomorrow, we plan to allow limited buys of these securities. We’ll continue to monitor the situation and may make adjustments as needed.

To be clear, this was a risk-management decision, and was not made on the direction of the market makers we route to.

Market Should Work

Although I believe there is a turnaround story for GameStop (NYSE: GME) and short squeeze is smart, it seems that the impact is more negative today. GME closed at $347.51 per share at 4pm, more than 4x the closing price I mentioned in Monday’s post. The negatives come from a few things:

1/ the story is not relevant to fundamentals now – however the healthiness of a functioning market depends on its ability to return to fundamental (in the long run).

2/ too much volatility + ripple effect of funds scaling back will cause additional chaos in the entire market. Some unnecessary negative feedback loop might form.

3/ people who entered the “casino” late probably won’t do well…

This mania may alert future participants/regulator, but may also set a bad example for markets globally.

The Case Of The Day – South Sea Company And GameStop

First last day of school for me!

In one of the courses today, we discussed the South Sea Company in 1720 in UK, when Sir Isaac Newton, representing “the smartest in the world”, didn’t do well in the stock market.

South Sea Company
Source: sovereignman.com

Also today, we saw news that Melvin Capital Management received $2.75 billion cash injection, as it has lost 30% in the first 3 weeks of 2021, due to its short bets including shorting GameStop (NYSE: GME). Melvin “had been one of the best performing hedge funds on Wall Street in recent years”, representing “the smartest of the smartest” in today’s world.

GameStop’s stock soared 245% in 2021 through Jan 22.

It closed at $6.68 on August 31, 2020, when Ryan Cohen revealed his 5.8 million shares purchase, or 9% stake. It closed at $76.79 today (Jan 25) – some 11.5x return if you buy at $6.68.

GameStop stock price in from Jan 19 – Jan 25 | Source: Yahoo Finance, author

The $2.75 billion cash includes $2 billion from Citadel and its partners, and $750 million from Point72. Melvin founder Gabe Plotkin was from Point72’s predecessor firm.

Takeaways:

1/ Predicting human behavior is much harder than physics or quarterly earnings.

2/ Leverage is the multiplier of actions.

3/ The “smartest” people might get it right – but lots of things can go wrong before that happens.

History Is Not A Straight Line Forward: Cannabis, Bitcoin, 3D Printing

History is not a straight line forward.

Setbacks are usual on the road. Plus, it takes time for new ideas to evolve into a better version of itself. As long as it represents a future that’s needed, it will come back from “disillusion”.

Instead of chasing the very new idea, investors looks back and brings past “bubbles” back to life – when they can show some real progress/changes.

Cannabis, Bitcoin and 3D printing are just three examples. It’s interesting to see the cycles forming, although 2-3 years might not be long enough to be called “big cycles”. That’s how the future arrives.

Future ways of living, of production and of how to organize the society are always the areas to invest – but be careful with bumps on the road.

1/ Cannabis

Cannabis stocks had a great performance in the second half of 2018 before they crashed. In the past few month, they are back to life with some 100-200%+ returns.

What has changed? People are expecting the US market to open up as legalization on the federal & states levels is under way. Price stabilizes, oversupply concerns are going away, more consolidation in the industry, and companies post strong growth and healthier gross margin in Q3.

Jan 1, 2017 – Jan 8, 2021 | ~2 years from the previous peak

 

2/ Bitcoin 

Bitcoin was called a “bubble” and is still called a “bubble” today. Bitcoin price hit $20k 3 years ago. Now it’s doubling the previous high to $40k.

What has changed? More people are seeing it as a hedge against USD depreciation as bitcoin’s supply is limited – it’s younger generation’s gold.

Jan 1, 2017 – Jan 8, 2021 | ~3 years from the previous peak

 

3/ 3D printing

3D printing was in a “hype” mode back in 2014 and quickly lost most of its “market cap” afterwards – just like cannabis and bitcoin.

What has changed? During COVID-19, when global supply chain was disrupted, people realized the value of flexibility of 3D printing, especially in medial equipment solutions. The 3D printing companies are also developing more “recurring” business model. With auto and other manufacturing sectors are expected to recover in 2021 and beyond, people are betting on a more “agile” future of the industrial world, with more customization and more flexible capex.

Jan 1, 2012 – Jan 8, 2021 | ~7 years from the previous peak

Charts are created by author, soured from WSJ

Airbnb’s IPO Plan & Capital Allocation

Airbnb did well in the past quarters before 2020 and doesn’t have much concerns for cash. It was one of the most financially healthy startup.

Actually, its full year earnings turned positive as early as 2017, when it generated earnings of about $100m while bookings grew around 150%. It became profitable in the second half of 2016.

In 2018, it made $93 million in profit on $2.6 billion in revenue.

More recently, it took in more than $1 billion in revenue in 2019Q2.

However, Airbnb racked up a $322 million net loss for the nine months through September, down from a $200 million profit a year earlier.

In 2019Q3 alone, Airbnb increased its revenue to $1.65 billion in the third quarter, up almost $400 million from a year earlier, one of the people said. But costs rose faster. Net profit for the quarter was $266 million – less than the $337 million profit for the same period in 2018

All sorts of reports said Airbnb is preparing to go IPO in 2020… until coronavirus hit.

When WSJ reported in Feb, it says Airbnb’s business in China is currently down about 80% compared with last year.

Now as travel industry worldwide is hit, Aribnb total revenue could decline 70-90% and might have cash flow problem.

It now has raised debt and cancelled summer internships.

In early April, Airbnb raised $1 billion in debt and equity from private equity firms Silver Lake and Sixth Street Partners.

Last week, Airbnb raised another $1 billion in debt. Fidelity, T Rowe Price and Blackrock are participating along with Apollo and Oaktree.

While Airbnb should be fine and solvent, how its revenue gonna recover & how to show its growth rate will be an IPO headache.

Occidental Petroleum (4): Agreement With Carl Icahn, Oil Price Plunge

According to the 13F-HR, Icahn held 33,244,429, 26,332,388 and 22,571,854 shares of Occidental as of June 30, September 30 and December 31, 2019.

Icahn’s fifth message on February 12, 2020.

Things evolved fast in 2020.

Oil prices plunged in March as COVID-19 developed and a price war started.

Line chart of Brent crude ($/barrel) showing Oil price crashes 30% after Saudi Arabia launches price war

Oil plunges 24% for worst day since 1991 after OPEC deal failure ...

Occidental’s stock price closed at $12.51 on March 9, dropping 53.4% from March 6 and 60.3% from March 5. The ex-div date was March 9, with $0.79 dividend per share announced in February.

The following day (March 10), Occidental reduced to quarterly dividend to $0.11 from 0.79, effective July 2020.

It also reduces 2020 capital spending to between $3.5 billion and $3.7 billion from $5.2 billion to $5.4 billion and will implement additional operating and corporate cost reductions.

Meanwhile, Icahn boosted its ownership close to 10% of Occidental.

On March 25, both parties reached agreement. Occidental will add three new Icahn designated directors to Occidental’s Board.

The Icahn Group has withdrawn its slate of director nominees and stockholder proposals at the 2020 Annual Meeting and agreed to vote in favor of the Board’s director nominees and amendments to Occidental’s restated certificate of incorporation that enhance Occidental’s corporate governance.

Under the agreement, the Icahn Group will petition the Delaware Supreme Court to withdraw its pending appeal before the Court relating to the Icahn Group’s books and records request under Section 220 of the Delaware General Corporation Law.

At the same time, Occidental further cut the capital spending to between $2.7 billion and $2.9 billion from its original 2020 guidance of $5.2 billion to $5.4 billion. The Company also announced it will reduce 2020 operating and corporate costs by at least $600 million compared to the original 2020 plan, including significant salary reductions for executive leadership. Operating cost reductions are expected to lower 2020 domestic operating costs to approximately $7.00 per BOE.

To further reserve cash, on April 15, Occidental elected to pay a quarterly $200 million payment it owes Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. in common shares, at a 10% discount. Occidental could choose to pay Berkshire differently in future quarters.

Occidental 2019 full year financial result | Earnings call transcript

Occidental Petroleum (3): Sweetened Bid, Carl Icahn

The Sweetened Winning Bid

On May 5, 2019, as part of the financing plan, Occidental entered into an agreement with Total to sell Anadarko’s African assets for for $8.8 billion , contingent on successfully completing the acquisition of Anadarko.

The assets to be sold to Total represent approximately 6% of the expected net production and approximately 7% of the cash flow after capital expenditures of Occidental in 2020 pro forma for the acquisition of Anadarko.

At the same time, Occidental increased the cash portion of its $76-per-share offer to a level that would allow it to make a bid that does not require the approval of its shareholders. Under the new terms, the offer comprises $59 in cash and 0.2934 shares of Occidental common stock per share of Anadarko. (78% Cash and 22% Stock)

This modification (of not requiring a shareholder vote) would become one of the major arguments brought by Carl Icahn later on.

Vicki Hollub, CEO of Occidental, also explains in her letter to Anadarko’s Board,

Our revised proposal does not require an Occidental shareholder vote, which has been repeatedly cited as the explanation for why you previously chose Chevron’s $65 offer over our $76 offer

Plus, the $1 billion breakup fee would be borne by Occidental after the acquisition.

The bidding war didn’t escalate.

On May 9, 2019, Occidental won the battle for Anadarko as Chevron exited bidding.

“Costs and capital discipline always matter,” Mr. Wirth said. “An increased offer would have eroded value to our shareholders.” Shares in Chevron rose 3.1% on Thursday. Occidental’s stock fell 6.4%, while Anadarko’s shares declined 3.2%.

Shareholders’ Discontent & Carl Icahn Coming

Along the bidding process, on the day (April 30) that Occidental secured Berkshire’s money, T. Rowe Price Group, one of the largest shareholders of Occidental Petroleum, says it opposes the energy company’s proposed merger with Anadarko Petroleum.

We think there is significant execution risk with the Anadarko deal and it would increase Occidental’s financial leverage significantly as well.

– John Linehan, manager at T Rowe Price Equity Income fund

On May 3, Bloomberg reported that Carl Icahn had built a small stake in Occidental Petroleum Corp.

Some investors expressed their intention to vote against approving Occidental’s Board.

At Occidental’s annual meeting in Houston on Friday (May 10), a proposal cutting the percentage of shareholders required to call a special meeting (from 25% to 15%) was backed by investors speaking for 60% of the shares voted, in defiance of opposition from Occidental’s board.

On May 30, Carl Icahn sued Occidenta over its acquisition of Anadarko, calling its $38 billion deal to buy Anadarko Petroleum Corp. “fundamentally misguided”.

Icahn argus that the Purchase is a Levered Bet on the Price of Oil, as Occidental’s debt (and debt-like preferred stock) increases from approximately $10 billion to over $45 billion.

The Icahn parties estimate that if the price of oil declines to approximately $45 per barrel or below for an extended period of time, Occidental might be forced to cut the common dividend. The warrants given to Berkshire alone were worth approximately $1.2 billion on the day the preferred deal was announced. And the singular focus to win the Anadarko bid at any cost prevented Occidental from
maximizing value in its sale of Anadarko’s African assets. [Court Document]

However, the complaint was to seek certain books and records relating to the Anadarko acquisition, etc. And eventually, in September 2019, the court ruled in favor of Occidental.

On June 26, in a preliminary copy, Icahn called for a special shareholder meeting where he plans to oust and replace four Occidental directors and change the company’s charter through a stockholder consent solicitation to prevent it from ever engineering a similar takeover again. [Icahn Solicitation Statement – Preliminary] [Icahn Solicitation Statement – Definitive]

On July 22, Icahn published an open letter to Occidental shareholders, four days after the definitive proxy statement was filed.

On August 8, Occidental announced that it has completed the acquisition of Anadarko.

[Icahn’s second and third open letters on August 13 and August 28]

In the third letter, Icahn opposed the two new board members (not in Icahn’s slate) proposed by Occidental.

On November 8, in his fourth open letter,

Earlier this year we owned over 33 million shares of OXY, but recently we reduced the size of our investment.  I still own almost 23 million shares, valued at almost $900 million, but this has become a very risky investment and without changing the incumbent Board and potentially the CEO, and in the absence of accountability for the OxyDarko Disaster, I am very concerned.

We fully intend to run a proxy fight, and if elected, work to right this teetering ship.

Occidental Petroleum (2): Topping Chevron’s Bid For Anadarko, Buffett’s Preferred Investment

Occidental Bids Anadarko Petroleum (APC)

Having grown into the No.1 operator in Permian in 2018Q4, Occidental definitely don’t want give that title back to Chevron.

While acquiring Anadarko is an add-on for Chevron, it’s much more financially challenging for Occidental.

Source: Chevron

Occidental produces at a similar scale as Anadarko. So it’s presumably an acquisition that would double its size.

But Occidental moved decisively. It offered $76.00 per share for Anadarko on April 24, 12 days after Chevron’s announcement, with ~17% premium over the $65 per share agreement. Taking into account the stock price movement, Occidental’s deal presents a ~20% premium.

Occidental’s offer also has more cash component (50/50) – $38.00 in cash and 0.6094 shares of Occidental common stock per Anadarko share, valuing Anadarko at $57 billion.

Occidental also argues a $3.5 billion free cash flow improvements through synergies and capital reduction, compared with Chevron’s $2 billion / year synergies.

Occidental actually tried to acquire Anadarko earlier in April, according to the press release later on.

It is unfortunate that Anadarko agreed to pay a break up fee of $1 billion, representing approximately $2 per share, without even picking up the phone to speak to us after we made two proposals during the week of April 8 that were at a significantly higher value to the transaction you were apparently negotiating with Chevron.

We noted to you on April 8 that our due diligence is complete. As you are aware, our financial advisors are BofA Merrill Lynch and Citi, and our legal advisors are Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and we and they are available to discuss any aspect of our proposal. We and our advisors have reviewed your merger agreement with Chevron. We are separately sending to you and your legal advisors a form of merger agreement on that basis which we would be prepared to enter into, subject to our agreeing to the disclosure schedules to be attached, together with a copy of our financing commitment letter.

Financing The Acquisition

Acquisition of this size is difficult for Occidental, especially as it offers much more cash than stocks.

In 2018, Occidental generated $7,669 million operating cash flows with $(4,975) million CapEx. It also paid $(2,374) million in cash dividend and bought back $(1,248) million stocks.

On its balance sheet as of the end of 2018, it had $3,033 million cash, and $10,317 million long-term debt.

On April 30, $10 billion financing was secured as Buffett came on board.

Berkshire Hathaway, Inc. has committed to invest a total of $10 billion in Occidental. The investment is contingent upon Occidental entering into and completing its proposed acquisition of Anadarko. Berkshire Hathaway will receive 100,000 shares of Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Stock with a liquidation value of $100,000 per share, together with a warrant to purchase up to 80.0 million shares of Occidental common stock at an exercise price of $62.50 per share.

The preferred shares also have a dividend rate of 8% per year.

As WSJ describes, the investment “is straight out of Warren Buffett’s playbook“. During and after the financial crisis, Berkshire acted as a lender of last resort for blue-chip companies including Goldman Sachs, General Electric and Bank of America.

Occidental marks Berkshire’s largest purchase of preferred shares; the 2013 Heinz deal has $8 billion preferred stocks and other securities.

Berkshire’s Preferreds | Source: WSJ

Mr. Buffett and Occidental have some shared history.

Mr. Buffett’s first stock purchase was three shares of Cities Service preferred stock when he was 11 years old. Occidental’s chief executive, Vicki Hollub, started her career at Cities Service, which was later acquired by Occidental. Cities Service is now called CITGO Petroleum Corp. and owned by Venezuela’s Petróleos de Venezuela SA.

「News of the Week」New York State Curve Flattening, Stock Market Up

On Tuesday (April 7), Gov. Andrew Cuomo projected that the state is reaching a plateau in coronavirus hospitalizations due to strict social distancing measures.

“To the extent that we see a flattening or a possible plateau, that’s because of what we’re doing and we have to keep doing it,” Mr. Cuomo said. (WSJ)

three day hospitalizations
Source: Cuomo press conference, Axios

The S&P 500 on Thursday (April 9) closed out its best four-day streak since 1974, up 11.9% (Dow up 12%). (CNBC)

CH 20200409_dow_best_weeks_close.png

Occidental Petroleum (1): Permian, Chevron Bid For Anadarko Petroleum

Occidental Petroleum (OXY) has been one of the most watched stock since 2019. Its stock lost ~80% compared with the start of 2018 and lagged behind Chevron and the industry later on.

OXY vs. XLE & CVX Jan 2018 – Apr 2020 | Source: Yahoo Finance, author

[XLE is State Street’s Energy Select Sector ETF fund; see its top holdings here]

Permian Oil Production

The Permian, the biggest shale basin in the US, has been one of the biggest drivers of a shale oil boom that helped make US the biggest oil producer in the world, ahead of Saudi Arabia and Russia.

Source: EIA

According to the March 2020 productivity report, output from the Permian basin of Texas and New Mexico, is expected to rise 38,000 bpd to a record 4.79 million barrels per day (bpd) in April 2020.

Texas continues to produce more crude oil than any other state or region of the United States, accounting for 41% of the US total in 2019.

Source: EIA
Source: EIA

As mentioned in Occidental’s 2019 annual report, Permian accounts for more than 30% of the total United States oil production; Occidental has a leading position in the Permian Basin, producing approximately 10% of the total oil in the basin.

Chevron Bids For Anadarko Petroleum (APC)

As the competition in Permian intensifies, with Occidental and Chevron two leading operators, companies are looking for M&A opportunities.

Anadarko Petroleum is the 11th largest operator in Permian Basin; its Permian production (127 mboe/d) accounted for ~18% of its 2018Q4 production of 701 mboe/d. [Occidental Acquisition Proposal Presentation April 2019]

A graphic with no description

Chevron, another major player in Permian, announced its acquisition agreement with Anadarko on April 12, 2019.

Chevron was the No.1 in 2018 whole year production in Permian, but lost that seat to Occidental in 2018Q4 as shown above. Growth by acquisition seems to be the way to go for Chevron.

Occidental Wins Battle for Anadarko as Chevron Exits Bidding - WSJ
Source: WSJ

The total enterprise value of the transaction is $50 billion. Anadarko’s equity is valued at $33 billion, or $65 per share. Based on Chevron’s closing price on April 11th, 2019 and under the terms of the agreement, Anadarko shareholders will receive 0.3869 shares of Chevron and $16.25 in cash for each Anadarko share. (75% stock and 25% cash)

[Read more on Chevron’s acquisition presentation]